Monday, July 31, 2023

God and More Than God: Was This The Thing That Split Church from Temple?

 “You believe that God is one, you do well.  Even the demons believe-and shudder.”  James 2:19.  So, demons believe and they shudder, that played large in our sermon this past Sunday.

But there is an even more powerful bit in that verse.  “You believe God is one…”  James was pressing on the understanding of God.

This is a complicated bit for Christianity.  Perhaps our largest presuppositional differences with our fellow religious siblings of Abraham, Islam and Judaism, is “One God” versus “God is One”.  It is a new thing for James.  He is writing to the twelve tribes of Israel in the Diaspora, those Jews dispersed beyond the Promised Land.  And he is pushing the accepted boundaries of how to understand God.

If I were going to attempt a scholarly treatise, I might say something like this is ‘a Theological consideration of the proto-Trinitarian understand of the Christian God.’  Almost sprains my brain to say that out loud.  Well, a theological consideration, that is code to tell us that in this moment, we are thinking about our faith, considering something about our faith. 

I am particularly proud of “proto-Trinitarian”.  Our understanding of God is well established in the Nicene and the Apostle’s Creeds, God the Father, God the Son, and God the Holy Spirit.  We draw that understanding as we think through how our God reveals Godself to us in the Bible.  And I say the Christian God, because this consideration is different from how I understand God to be understood in Judaism. 

Maybe this is the place where Judaism and Christianity broke ranks.  We know that the church began among the Jews.  That it spread to Gentile believers.  I have always thought of that as the reason for the breaking point, that the Gentile ‘wing’ of the church became far larger than the Jewish ‘wing’, that in the opening up of the traditional laws of Moses, things became untenable between the two communities.

Maybe this is the point of breakage.  A fancy title like “proto-Trinitarian” simply means “before Trinitarian”.  Before there was a full development of the theology of, the thinking about God in God’s revealed form, that we understand as “Trinity”, three-in-one.  Maybe what James is getting at in this understanding that “God is one” is the expanded revelation of God, from only God the Father, to God the Father and God the Son.  This is not to dismiss the person or importance of the Holy Spirit, but to understand how Christianity grew away from Judaism, in stages.

Which connects us to where our preaching comes from this month, from the Gospel according to John.  We, okay-I, Bible nerd, am going to have a lot of fun with origin stories about the Gospels.  John “versus” the Synoptics, Matthew, Mark, and Luke.  Yes, I will elaborate on that in the future.  But I want to look particularly at the opening of the Gospel of John, the ‘creation story’ of the New Testament.

“In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God.  He was in the beginning with God.  All things came into being through him, and without him not one thing came into being.  What has come into being in him was life, and the life was the light of all people.  The light shines in the darkness and the darkness did not overcome it.”  (John 1: 1-5)

The Word is Jesus.  Jesus was in the beginning.  Jesus was with God.  Jesus was God.  Jesus was in the beginning with God.  All things came into being through Jesus.  And it goes on from there.  The gospel writer is not laying out a specified “Duality” of God (first God is two and then three-when we add the Holy Spirit in John 14).  That kind of organizational thinking comes later. 

No, what is happening here, what James is pushing on, is the expanded understanding of God.  Jesus the Messiah?  That works in the theology of the Old Testament-how the Old Testament presents its thinking about God.  Son of David works.  Even Son of God, although that is skating near the edges of a Unity understanding of God (JUST God the Father).

But Jesus was God.  That is the gauntlet thrown down.  That is the dividing wall between Christianity and what came before.  This is what we believe the Old Testament points toward but it is only here where it becomes such a bold statement of intent. 

The other gospels have their own introductions to set Jesus in context.  The most explicit introduction to set things up comes in Luke.  He is writing to someone named Theophilus to give them the rundown on this new thing that is happening.  Luke is Book 1, Acts is Book 2.  Matthew sets the context by laying down Jesus’ lineage, his genealogy back to Abraham.  Mark begins where the narrative portion of John begins, at the baptism of John. 

But John backs it up.  Takes his cue from Genesis.  In the beginning…  The first chapters of Genesis are often seen as a Divine Prologue, huge displays of God’s power, people lived for centuries, the Flood, the Tower of Babel, all coming off the Creation.  The human story begins with Abraham.  John sets up his Divine Prologue in 6 verses.  This is what we will find in his Gospel.  The human story begins with John the Baptist (ANOTHER John-and ANOTHER post).  Jesus was, is, and ever shall be God.

Peace,

Pastor Peter

No comments: